Jane Rogers and her friend Ashley Lane are making Valentine’s Day cookies, with lots of light flirting. When Jane’s stepbrother Tyler Nixon joins them in the kitchen only to taunt them, the girls kick him out of the kitchen and then decide to get revenge on him. They strip off until they’re just wearing their aprons, then call Tyler back to the kitchen. They advertise that Tyler cannot and cannot have cookies.
Tyler isn’t happy about girls telling him what he can and can’t do, so he steals a cookie and leaves. The girls manage to pull Tyler’s pants down to stop him, but he escapes. Jane chases him to the couch, where she tackles him to retrieve the cookie. When Jane leans back, Tyler gets right into that juicy pussy. Jane freaks out a bit, but she likes how nice and thick Tyler’s stick of shit is. Ashley loves watching Jane and her stepbrother fuck her so much that she insists on joining. Soon Jane got off the D so she could share a blowjob with Ashley.
Ashley enjoys Tyler’s hard cock in doggy style while she and Jane kiss. Finally, Jane gets on her knees in front of Ashley’s face so her friend can devour her. Then Jane rolls onto her back with Tyler pounding her cream filled hole and Ashley riding her face. Ashley turns on her back with Jane on top of her to present a double pussy stack for Tyler to keep pounding. When the girls are finally satisfied that Tyler has earned their cookie, they roll over for one last mutual BJ until Tyler pops into their mouths to give them a treat to share.